« New Theme | Main | Obama: Doctor to the World Economy »

Friday, June 08, 2012

Comments

A.I.

Once again you misrepresent Krugman by taking comments out of context. If "we are in this pickle only because of a calamitous fall in public spending by the state governments." is a direct quote from Krugman, it would be against the backdrop that private sector job creation has been reasonably good over recent quarters but is offset to a great extent by loss of state and local government jobs. Rectifying that situation would require federal assistance for state and local grovernments which, absent increased tax revenue, would resulting in greater federal debt. It has nothing to do with states taking on debt. It has to do with saving jobs.

Nor does Krugman say the initial economic collapse was the result of low government spending at any level. He only says once the collapse occurred, business and personal spending shrank meaning the only segment of the economy left to spur growth was (and is) increased government spending. And once private sector economic activity reaches a reasonable level, he advocates reduced federal spending and deficits.

Ken Blanchard

A.I.: when I quote someone, I use quotation marks or other unmistakable devices. I think I get Krugman right. The crisis in Europe is a result of easy credit lent to Greece et. al. by the EC. Krugman wants the Fed to pour billions into the states so that they can spend it on what? High speed railroads between ghost towns?

Yes, Krugman says that we should begin spending responsibly in the future, just not now. The things you believe.

Donald Pay

The problem is KB sees no difference between Greece and the United States. Most sane people do. KB climbs aboard one of Europe high speed trains, and that's where he goes off the rails.

So, we've had the high speed rail discussion before, and KB is basically right about that. It's really not worth dumping money into, except as a pilot project in a dense corridor. But weaning ourselves off oil and coal is something worthwhile.

But where are we to look for KB's answer to all our problems? Well, to the "courageous" (KB's word) Scott Walker who frittered away all those supposed "savings" from robbing state workers on tax breaks and give aways to the wealthy and corporate elite, not on balancing the state budget. Yes, all that supposed savings went to fill the hole Walker made by reopening the Nevada loophole, where funds are shifted to Nevada or the Cayman Islands to be laundered so it won't show up as taxable income in Wisconsin.

So what did Walker do to make the budget look balanced. He did what KB says he shouldn't do--he put it all on the credit card. Does KB not understand his heros are spend and borrow liberals?

Ken Blanchard

Yeah, Donald. It's me and the CBO and the trustees of Social Security and Medicare vs. all you sane people. I can hardly resist your logic. US is not Greece; ergo, US doesn't have to worry about debt.

The comments to this entry are closed.